“For there is one God, and one mediator between God and men, a man, Christ Jesus.” (New World Translation – NWT)
The Watchtower’s Insight book volume 2 page 360 defines Mediator this way,
“One who interposes between two parties at variance to reconcile them; an intercessor; an intermediary agent, or go-between.”
As a Jehovah’s Witness (JW) I always believed that Jesus was my Mediator, especially when I look at a definition like the one above. After all, when we pray in Jesus’ name, is that not recognizing Jesus as the Mediator or “go between” or perhaps “intercessor” between us and the Father? If you were to ask the average JW publisher the question, “Is Jesus your Mediator?” I feel very confident that the vast majority would emphatically say, YES! Even when I was serving as a ministerial servant (deacon), I was sure that Jesus was my Mediator. It was while the Circuit Overseer was visiting that I was asked to say the closing prayer for the meeting, and it was at this point that something was brought to my attention. I closed the prayer with these words,
“We pray in the name of your Son, our King and Mediator Jesus Christ, Amen.”
The reason I remember this so well is because the instant I stepped off of the platform an elder approached me and he kindly told me that Jesus was not my Mediator. Naturally, this set me back a bit. I looked him in the eye and I said, “What?” He then said,
“Jesus is your Ransomer, but he is not your Mediator. He is Mediator only for the 144,000.”
Being a ministerial servant at the time, I wasn’t going to challenge his statement without thoroughly researching what he said. So that evening I went home and began my study from the Watchtower CD-ROM to see if what this brother said was true. Much to my surprise and disappointment, I found that according to the Watchtower organization Jesus is not my Mediator. The Watchtower teaches that Jesus is not Mediator for the great crowd, but He is Mediator for only the 144,000.
I personally find this belief not only highly offensive, but also immoral on the part of the Watchtower! If you are a JW and a member of the “great crowd,” please ask yourself the following questions;
1) If Jesus is not my Mediator then who is?
2) If Jesus is not my Mediator then why do I pray in Jesus’ name?
3) If Jesus is not my Mediator, does Jehovah hear my prayers?
4) If Jesus is not my Mediator, then how do I apply 1Timothy 2:5?
5) If Jesus is not my Mediator, can His blood cover my sins?
6) If Jesus is not my Mediator, how do I explain the Insight book’s definition of Mediator?
7) If Jesus is not my Mediator, why are we not sacrificing animals?
8 ) Do I believe what the Bible says about Jesus’ role as Mediator, or what the Watchtower teaches?
Just recently I asked my wife, a lifelong JW who is still devout and exemplary in the local congregation, if she believed that Jesus was her Mediator. She said with no hesitation whatsoever, “Absolutely!” When I told her the Watchtower’s point of view her exact words were,
“Well, I’m not sure what the Watchtower says about it, but I know for a fact that Jesus is my Mediator.”
All I can say about her comment is that I praise God that she knows and accepts Jesus as her Mediator in spite of what the Watchtower teaches!
I mentioned above that I consider the organization’s teaching on this subject as immoral. Here’s why. Over the years, through my studies, I have come to the understanding that the Watchtower has set themselves (the governing body) up as a false or “anti-type” mediator for the “great crowd.” They have actually put themselves in the place of Jesus in several ways, but for the sake of brevity here are just two;
First, by requiring that JW’s report their sins to the elders for true forgiveness to take place. Ultimately, in the organization, the decision as to whether or not the individual is repentant is decided by the elders. They base this decision upon how the person responds to their questions and upon the information provided by the Watchtower Society in either the “shepherding book” or Watchtower articles regarding the sin at hand. Yet, the organization has the audacity to criticize the Catholic Church for having a confessional. What’s the difference? The truth is, forgiveness comes from true repentance and from faith in the shed blood of our Mediator Jesus Christ! Not from men! (1John 1:9-2:3)
Secondly, the Watchtower’s governing body has set themselves up in the place of the Holy Spirit. I can honestly say this because they are the ones who teach and interpret all Scripture for all JW’s. Yet in the Bible we are told that this is the job of God’s Holy Spirit (See John 14:26 and 1John 2:20 &27) Once again the Watchtower criticizes The Catholic Church for doing this, yet the organization is guilty of the very same thing. What hypo-crisy! (See Watchtower 3/15/63 pages 169-170 paragraph 6) You can find this reference in my article, Can You Understand The Bible?
Without the rank and file Jehovah’s Witness realizing it, the organization has actually robbed them of their perfect King, Mediator and High Priest by replacing Him with a group of deluded, imperfect men. The governing body has cut the “great crowd of Jehovah’s Witnesses” off from the heavenly kingdom and has created a 2 class society. Jesus warned the religious leaders of His day about this very thing in Matthew 23:13 when He said,
“Woe to YOU, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! because YOU shut up the kingdom of the heavens before men; for YOU yourselves do not go in, neither do YOU permit those on their way in to go in. (NWT)
If you are a Jehovah’s Witness, please prayerfully and carefully consider the above questions and know that Jesus is your Mediator. Don’t let a group of men rob you of your relationship with God and His Son Jesus. Psalm 118:8-9 says,
“It is better to trust in Jehovah than to trust in man; 9 it is better to trust in Jehovah than to trust in nobles.” (LITV)
So once again my question for you is, do you believe Jesus is your Mediator as the Bible says, or do you choose to trust in men by following the Watchtower’s interpretation?